As the title suggests

0 It's there but I dont care
1-3 being a mild irritation
4-6 Quiet irritating but livable with
7-8 Very irritating - I dont use my car as much as I would due to this noise
9-10 I hate it and cant live with it

Last edited by The doc on Wed Dec 13 2006 11:36pm. Edited 1 time in total

8-9 Very irritating - I dont use my car as much as I would due to this noise

8 - It significantly reduces the pleasure of driving an otherwise good vehicle.

5- Fortunately we have very good road surfaces around here, but drivem me mad when I visit the office in west Yorkshire.

Note that mine only does this noise in a straight line, not when steeringis turned, and we have an awful ot of bends on the Lake District roads.

9 - hate the knock, love the car..

Over the last 8 months "water-knock" has successfully affected:
1. my blood pressure,
2. my marriage (wife keeps telling me to drop my quest for fair treatment from LR, causes substantial disagreement),
3. my time-keeping record at work (countless days out to take the car to the dealers for nothing to get done, boss fed up with it),
4. my general state of mental well-being (I have started going slightly mad).

Doc - thankyou. You're doing a grand job, I'm feeling better already.

Nod RRS Supercharged
Java/ Ivory

'94 F355, '90 M3 Evo, '95 Integrale Evo, '97 Cooper S Works, '84 911 Cab, '89 911 Speedster, '85 6R4, '59 Routemaster and something sensible for the Mrs

Does this lack of response mean no one else has experienced a problem and therefore those above are isolated instances of something other than the Dynamic Response noise?

Doc

I am convinced your suspension drop has damaged the suspension somewhere and your dealer, on the back of how LR are instructing their dealers to treat complaints of "the suspension is producing knocking noises", has not bothered to look for the real source of your problem. It would be nice for you and the rest of us (and I've still got a 6 month wait for mine) for you to report back next week that Hillendale have remedied the problem.

rrsjo wrote:

Does this lack of response mean no one else has experienced a problem and therefore those above are isolated instances of something other than the Dynamic Response noise?

Doc

I am convinced your suspension drop has damaged the suspension somewhere and your dealer, on the back of how LR are instructing their dealers to treat complaints of "the suspension is producing knocking noises", has not bothered to look for the real source of your problem. It would be nice for you and the rest of us (and I've still got a 6 month wait for mine) for you to report back next week that Hillendale have remedied the problem.

Lack of resopnse might be because some of us havnt had time to read the threads because we are working. I am not sure what my knocking noise is but i would rate it as 4-6 (which is the same category as my wife)

Envoy

Just trying to provoke a response

rrsjo wrote:

Does this lack of response mean no one else has experienced a problem and therefore those above are isolated instances of something other than the Dynamic Response noise?

I only posted this on:Wed Dec 13 2006 @ 2:01pm !

Doc

I am convinced your suspension drop has damaged the suspension somewhere and your dealer, on the back of how LR are instructing their dealers to treat complaints of "the suspension is producing knocking noises", has not bothered to look for the real source of your problem. It would be nice for you and the rest of us (and I've still got a 6 month wait for mine) for you to report back next week that Hillendale have remedied the problem.

Agreed - this posting from LR seems to have given certain LR dealers an excuse to not repair any front end noises

dont have the noise so cant reply

5 - but mine hasn't got dynamic response. Is the watery thingy that VOR talks about a Dynamic Response feature, or one fited to all RRS's.

By the way, our D3 makes a similar noise at times but probably only rate that at 2 on The Doc's scale.

Did you know that Landrover spelt in Emoticons looks like :

 RRS TDv8 HSE Rimini
Disco 4 TDv6 HSE Ipanema
Defender 90, 200tdi CSW

"5 - but mine hasn't got dynamic response"

lol it simply must have because notheing else ever goes wrong on these cars

Smarticus, there are too many letters.  Arctic Frost TDV6 SE. Aspen Leather, Cherry Wood, Privacy Glass, PTI, Tow Pack, Mudflaps, Tasmods, a new Fuelflap, a RRSport.co.uk umbrella in the boot & a RRSport.co.uk sticker on the rear glass.
__________________

Some people accuse me of thinking the world revolves around me, but I'm not stupid . . . I know it revolves around the sun. Which shines out of my @rse!!!

The ARC knock described in VOR's post is only associated with vehicles fitted with dynamic response.

Unfortunately, the route cause of your annoying little knock lies elsewhere Smarticus. Arctic Frost TDV6 SE. Aspen Leather, Cherry Wood, Privacy Glass, PTI, Tow Pack, Mudflaps, Tasmods, a new Fuelflap, a RRSport.co.uk umbrella in the boot & a RRSport.co.uk sticker on the rear glass.
__________________

Some people accuse me of thinking the world revolves around me, but I'm not stupid . . . I know it revolves around the sun. Which shines out of my @rse!!!

Agreed! - I bet he gets the "water knock" letter / reason...